The Shadow of Anakin Part I: Why Kylo and Anakin are Nothing Alike

kylo starkiller

Though Anakin Skywalker has been dead for thirty years, the specter of his memory still looms over the Star Wars universe. His shadow is most obviously personified by his grandson: Kylo Ren, a young fanatic seduced by the dark side, obsessed with Vader’s exploits, and striving to live up to Vader’s legacy. A Skywalker, powerful in the Force, and obsessed with power and willing to hurt those he loves to get it. It seems like Kylo is well on his way to filling Vader’s boots.

The comparison between Vader and Kylo is an interesting one because while their narratives seem alike on the surface, a deeper look reveals that not to be the case at all. Sure, they both crave power from the dark side, they’re both angsty, they have scary masks, and they both see no problem in hurting those they care about in their quest for power and glory. But, for all Kylo’s Vader fanboyism and desire to emulate his grandfather, the two characters actually share very few similarities when it comes to their pursuit of power. And that is going to play a key role in how their redemption narratives play out.

Obviously we know very little about the details of Ben’s backstory, so a significant part of this is based on speculation drawn from context clues present in The Force Awakens. But based on what we see of Kylo and what we can surmise about the state of the galaxy, it’s clear that Vader and Kylo are actually quite different in how they fell to the dark side. And that difference is due to a couple key aspects of their pre-dark side selves, Anakin and Ben.

Firstly, Ben was born free.

That needs its own line because it is probably the most significant difference between the two. Ben was born free whereas Anakin was not. And this goes deeper than just the literal fact that Anakin was born into slavery while Ben wasn’t. Ben starts with everything that Anakin ever wanted.

Ben was born to a family that loved him and whom he was openly allowed to love in return. Obviously we don’t know for a fact that Luke did away with the “no attachment” rule of the former Jedi Order. But we do know that Ben’s fall to the dark side was what drove Han and Leia apart, and that Snoke expressed concern that Ben wouldn’t be able to put his emotions for his father aside. Both of these suggest that Ben had a loving relationship with his family and wasn’t taken from them as a baby, nor was he discouraged from being emotionally attached to them.

Furthermore, Ben could be reasonably assured of the safety of the people he loved. Though we don’t know many details on the rise of the First Order, the opening crawl seems to suggest that it was the absence of Luke Skywalker that led to their prominence as a force to be reckoned with (and Luke’s disappearance is a result of Ben turning to the dark side). So up until Ben’s fall, the galaxy was presumably a peaceful place. He didn’t have the looming specter of war to place his loved ones in danger, and he didn’t have loved ones still enslaved on dangerous Outer Rim planets.

In contrast, Anakin barely knew what freedom was. Yes, obviously, he spent the first nine years of his life as a literal slave. But upon being freed from slavery he almost immediately joins the Jedi Order. And while the Jedi Order isn’t literally comparable to slavery, it is its own sort of servitude: Anakin isn’t free to travel the galaxy as he wishes or go visited the only family and friends he ever knew. He is expected to do as his masters say.

While Anakin was born to a mother that clearly loved him, he was expected to sever all emotional ties to her upon entering the Order. Certainly not an easy task for a nine year old whose mother was probably the only positive and loving figure in his life as a slave. Furthermore, when Anakin begins to have prophetic dreams about her death he isn’t allowed to do anything about it. Arriving at the Tusken village just in time to witness her death leaves him wracked with guilt for not being able to save her. And it plants the first major seeds of resentment and distrust in the Jedi Order; after all, if it weren’t for them forbidding attachments then he might have been able to save his mother. And then of course all this guilt is only amplified when it comes to his secret relationship with Padmé. His fear of losing Padmé is what starts him down the slippery slope towards the dark side.

Freedom to openly love those he loved, and freedom to be sure that his loved ones were safe. That was really all Anakin ever wanted. Ben started with all of that and for some reason gave it up; Anakin never really had it in the first place and kept grasping for it. Because of this, their approach to power (and therefore, their respective falls) are vastly different.

anakin mustafar
And we all know where good intentions lead

Anakin, by my interpretation, was never interested simply in power. What he wanted was power to. Power to free slaves. Power to save his mother. Power to end the war. Power to save Padmé the way he couldn’t save his mother. Power to feel as though he was the master of his own life and had some measure of control.

Anakin’s fall is ultimately the tale of good intentions gone horribly wrong. His fall is the story of a man driven desperate by fear, who seeks power in the wrong place, and who ultimately loses everything and finds himself a slave all over again. One gets the sense that Anakin wasn’t after dark side power specifically, just that it was the only option that (apparently) presented a solution to his problem. By Return of the Jedi, one gets the sense that he doesn’t even particularly want to be on the dark side; he just simply sees no other way out.

Does this excuse any of Vader’s actions? Of course not. Anakin may have had good intentions but he still slaughtered children and was responsible for the deaths and suffering of thousands. But it makes a difference in his redemption arc, as I’ll discuss more fully on Wednesday.

Ben, in contrast, seems to be after power for power’s sake. We know little about the details of Ben’s fall, but we can infer several things. First is that Ben apparently had everything that Anakin wanted (freedom to love his family and reasonable assurance of their safety) and yet voluntarily gave it all up. We also know that he idolizes Vader (not Anakin) to a fanatical degree. Finally, we know that he struggles with the light; Rey even says that his greatest fear is that he will never be as strong as Darth Vader.

The inverse of that last statement is that Ben fears his own vulnerability most of all. He wants to be fully of the dark side and is disgusted with himself whenever he falls short. He even goes so far as to kill his own father in order to cement his place in the dark. This makes clear that Ben’s fall is less a case of good intentions gone horribly wrong and more of a series of deliberate steps towards the dark side. While Anakin saw the dark side as a means to an end, Ben sees the dark side as the end. Unlike Anakin, Ben doesn’t want power to; he just wants power.

So what does that mean for Kylo Ren? Can a person who deliberately chooses to step towards the dark and away from the light ever find redemption? Is there still a part of Ben somewhere in Kylo, just as there was still a part of Anakin in Vader? It’s certainly going to be a more difficult path than Anakin’s. Ben is far more fanatical in his dark side beliefs than Anakin was and seems determined to follow in Vader’s footsteps. But while the shadow of Vader looms over Kylo, the shadow of Anakin does as well. And if history is anything to go by, Ben might still have a chance.

Check back Wednesday for a closer look at Anakin’s legacy in a galaxy far, far away and what that means in terms of a redemption for Kylo Ren.

5 thoughts to “The Shadow of Anakin Part I: Why Kylo and Anakin are Nothing Alike”

  1. This is fascinating!

    One of the things we don’t know in terms of the story is *why* Ben falls to the dark side… what seduces him. We know the seduction of Anakin – we can even sympathize with him. With Ben, we just know that Snoke is the one who tempted him. From there it is speculation — although its going to be the hinge that determines whether or not Ben’s redemption is satisfying (or whether he is turned into a tragic object lesson).

    If I had to guess, I would say that what is going to happen is that we are going to see a big discussion of worldview. It got touched on in the OT and PT — the truths we hold depend upon our point of view, from my point of view the Jedi are evil, etc. But what has happened with the First Order is a totally distorted worldview, a warped view of reality.

    How did Snoke get Ben to look at the universe through the lenses that made Kylo Ren seem like the logical and reasonable choice?

    It doesn’t seem to be passion, or jealousy, or greed. I can’t really pick a classical vice… perhaps it will be guilt. Who knows?

    Whatever way it goes, it will be fun!

    Thanks for a great article, and I look forward to Wednesday!

    1. Thanks, I’m glad you enjoyed it!

      Yes, I am really looking forward to discovering the details of Kylo’s backstory. I remember reading in an article somewhere (that I have since lost track of) that either JJ or Adam Driver said he turned because of a “perceived betrayal.” But that’s such a vague statement that it could account for a wide range of scenarios.

      I agree that guilt might be a big reason for why Ben keeps deliberately choosing to go towards the dark. All his comments about “struggling with the light” read (to me) as someone who knows deep down that he’s made a mistake but doesn’t want to admit it and so will keep doing more and more drastic things to reassure himself he’s on the right path. Basically, it’s an escalation of commitment/sunk costs fallacy combination.

    2. I agree, both that this is an excellent article and that there is a lot we don’t yet know.

      Especially interesting to me is the mystery of Kylo’s views of Vader – he promises to “finish what Vader started,” but it’s not yet clear to me what he means by this. Destroy the Jedi? If so, why? I think your analysis of Vader is spot-on, but what is Kylo’s understanding of Vader? Until we know what Snoke told him about Vader, I think it is difficult to assess what exactly is going on with his character. After all, the Star Wars universe is full of characters who willingly embraced the Dark Side in some misguided quest of self-sacrifice to achieve the greater good (Anakin most of all, but Legends contained many other examples). I’m not sure we have enough context yet to say what Kylo is trying to accomplish.

      I also think that there is going to be a lot of heartbreak in the coming movies for fans of the original trilogy, because I don’t think that a person ends up where Kylo ends up without having some sort of family trauma, and that means that Leia, Han, and Luke failed him at some point in his upbringing. Perhaps it was something small that was blown out of proportion in Kylo’s imagination, but I can’t imagine him having had a particularly happy home life. While I agree that whatever traumas occurred for Kylo will likely pale in comparison with those of Anakin’s childhood, I don’t see any way to make Kylo a well-rounded character without there being some failing on the part of Leia, Han, and Luke in raising and training him. It’s not going to be pleasant for those of us who like to imagine the Big Three as having a happily-ever-after following Endor, but I think it is going to be a natural part of a Sequel Trilogy that stars the OT characters and their children.

  2. I’ll put in another thanks for the interesting article.

    The only thing that I have to add is that I’m not even sure anymore that Ben going to the Dark Side is what caused Leia and Han to split. When they talk at the Resistance base, there’s dialogue along the lines of (I’m going to skip punctuation to avoid adding my interpretation too soon):
    Leia: [sending Ben to train with Luke] is when I lost him that’s when I lost you both
    Han: we both had to deal with it in our own way

    On my first viewing, I thought the course of events was:
    1 Ben starts training with Luke
    2 Ben goes to the Dark Side
    3 Leia and Han split

    On some later viewing, I started wondering if maybe the sequence was:
    1 Ben does something or reacts to something in a worrying way that prompts Leia to send him to Luke
    2 Han responds to Ben’s action / reaction by leaving
    3 The training doesn’t have the desired effect and Ben goes to the Dark Side

    Basically, I started thinking that the “it” Han said they both had to deal with was Ben going to the Dark Side (my first thought and I still think the more likely one) or else something that is why Leia sent Ben to Luke for training, but we really don’t know. Unless if I misheard that dialogue and I’m making up dialogue here.

Comments are closed.